The Guardian’s Matthew Norman is either derelict or diabetic in his duties

My first objection to Norman’s review of The Crown Inn in the London commuter county of Buckinghamshire may sound like a quibble, but it does illustrate his propensity to base his pronouncements on thin evidence. He samples but two of the mains on offer (6 on the menu + daily specials), yet claims to have backed “the main course winner”. Sorry, Matthew, but you cannot follow just two horses in the Grand National and be confident that one of them is THE winner.

My second objection is the greater neglect. The restaurant critic for the magazine of a major national newspaper does not assess a single dessert. His pretext for not doing his job? The portions “are too geared towards the needs of the famished wayfarer to leave room for even so tempting a pud as treacle tart with clotted cream.”

Sorry, Matthew, but if part of your enviable job is to critique the components of a meal and you fear you may be getting too stuffed from your main course to contemplate dessert there is an easy solution: push away your plate, unfinished. Only after sampling the puds may you conclude they are worth skipping.

2 Comments

  1. Gastro1

    Matthew Norman & AA Gill are not food critics they write copy that mentions food .They have no gastronomic education.

    Reply
  2. msmarmitelover

    hehe love your blog

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Post

No Happy Monday in Manchester for Jay Rayner

When Jay Rayner arrived for lunch at Obsidian on a damp Manchester Monday he found a restaurant unprepared to serve any punter, much less the restaurant critic of The Observer. "A restaurant trading outside of its most appropriate hours", mused Rayner in his 4th of...

read more

Guardian says Chinese disrespect veg

While many attack the Chinese for repressing human rights or restraining the value of their currency, The Guardian Weekend magazine's Matthew Norman may be the first opinion writer for a major national newspaper to call them out en masse for undervaluing their...

read more

BRING YOUNG & FOODISH HOME

As a member of the Young & Foodish community, you’ll hear about our latest food discoveries, recipes, videos, live sessions, product recommendations, parties and at-home events. We’ll help you lead a more foodish life.

Welcome to the Young & Foodish community.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This